Rantings on a Saturday Night
I’ve been wondering, but I don’t recall hearing a joke that starts with “The Prophet Muhammad, blah and blah walks into a bar...” I guess I could think one up, but I’m not going to be poking an angry beast with a pointy stick at this time. Assuming there is a joke like that floating around out there and it isn’t intended to be offensive or blasphemous, would that be alright? Okay, the “bar” part might be a problem, so let’s change that to “juice bar” or something really, really neutral. Again I ask: if the joke does not mean to give offence, would we still be seeing what we see today? I mean, would the Muslim masses take to the street and threaten all things West that remotely connects to the origin of the joke? Yes and no, I think. I believe some Muslims would take to the street wielding an AK-47 for just about any reason they can find. I do also believe, however, that some have a sense of humour. You know, the ones who aren’t always angry/bitter/hateful and who believe the world should be subjected to them or at least owe them something.
I am, of course, referring to the current upheaval about the cartoons about the prophet Muhammad that were published in a Danish newspaper last year (I don’t know why it’s only erupting now). I’ve been meaning to write about this for a week now and thought that the topic would be old and stale now, but after reading today’s newspaper, I know the fight is still going strong. The problem is two-fold: in Islam, it is blasphemous to depict holy figures in drawings, paintings and the like, the least of which not being caricatures. Secondly, some of the cartoons (with reference to one in particular) where very stereotypical about the West’s view of Muslims which is, bottom line, offensive, even to the non-zealots.
Being true to tradition, the West has very neatly summarized everything and placed it into pretty little categories: freedom of speech vs. respect of other nations and religions. Very tidy: something that makes for a good old fashioned debate in churches, schools, universities, water coolers and cigarette breaks. The West likes to believe they are very open minded, so everything is tolerated and considered for a while. Well, that’s what the ideology says.
Here’s a very concise version of what I think is the dirty little truth. Europe doesn’t like having to have non-Europeans in their midst. We saw it with the Jews and today we see it with the Muslims. They just don’t like throwing their doors open to strange folk who come in with strange customs and religions and eventually threaten their way of life. The problem is that the minorities aren’t minor anymore. Remember Paris? After September 11 some people feel that Arabs are free game for ridicule and blame and I guess a constant search for attacks on them eventually led to “The Cartoons”.
Muslims, on the other hand, just love to play the victim card. Wait, that’s more the Palestinians, but the fact is that they just love a good old rally with posters and protests and stuff. They are so sick and tired of everyone and everything else. The truth is that if the immigration situation was reversed (Europeans flooding the Arabian countries), the Europeans would probably have been treated just as worse, if not more. It’s a question of identity and “birds of a feather, flock together”. As a rule of thumb, different cultures aren’t compatible.
Freedom of Speech is a joke. There is no country in the world that has total freedom of speech. Some are just worse than others. To my knowledge, only “interregnum Germany” (pre-NAZI) briefly had total freedom of speech (i.e. absolutely no censorship whatsoever). Censorship is needed to protect against things like (child-) pornography and to protect governments from complots that sprout from dissent. Freedom of speech does not exist, so don’t ever come crying crocodile tears by me about it.
I am not a supporter of the Muslims, on the contrary. I do believe that some people are dealing with this in a proper and honourable manner, but that the most are irrational and vindictive. I also believe that certain things just shouldn’t be done.
Reading the newspaper today, I found an article entitled “Is it okay to hate Jews again?”. The article focused the growing amount of anti-Semitism that can be found not only among the protesting Muslims (apparently Jews should be blamed for the Danish cartoons...) but also among middle to upper class Westerners. As the author said, anti-Semitism flourished in Europe for nearly 2000 years and then just disappeared after the Holocaust (which is being contest anew by both Muslims and Westerners). It was probably unrealistic to think that it was gone for good, but the fact is that Jews and Israel are taking flak from multiple sides now. For me that’s just very sad, especially after I personally heard an anti-Semitic comment being made.
The problem is that issues are very rarely, if every, neatly catagorizable. There is almost always a myriad of other underlying issues.
I don’t want to say anything more about this issue. I’ve said more or less what I want. I’ll probably regret it or want to add or re-write some of it later, but I won’t, because it is not my intention of getting involved in this debate. This isn’t my fight and for all I care both sides can go jump into some sort of large body of water. There is merely one issue I want to raise: why would such radical reactions never be seen from Christians? The media is littered with blasphemous comics and sayings that have become commonplace. What would happen if all the Christians take to the streets to boycott all the cartoons, movies, television shows and publications that are blasphemous? What would happen if Hollywood is given an ultimatum over it’s beloved “oh my g*d” phrase? Sadly, we’ll never find out. Besides, even if that did happen, the rest of the world just wouldn’t care and continue as they would. Indeed, we would see and increase in blasphemous material. Yay for the little world we live in!
Having been docile for a couple of months now, it seems the bird flu scare is back with a vengeance: Nigeria, France, Germany and Egypt, amongst others, within a week? This is getting interesting.
I got a new phone last week! Yay. I’m terrible sorry, but I just had to mention that. It’s a Sony Ericsson K750i: the one I really wanted! This is the first time I have ever had a top-of-the-line (that I care about) phone. I’m not planning on turning into a yuppie now, but I am enjoying the GPRS and Java while the novelty still lasts (and it still does).
This evening feels very strange. Up until just now the streets felt unnervingly quiet. In Bellville the sky was filled with a thick cloud and mist blurred the near empty streets’ lights. Here, in Stellenbosch, the sky is clear and stars glisten as brightly as I haven’t seen them in a very long time. Everywhere it is very hot and I wonder why more people have not been enticed to go outside to enjoy the sweet and intoxicating summer’s night. I also have this strange feeling of having to be somewhere doing something. I know what it is, but that is just my ego and that insecure little boy inside thinking out loud. I am also aware of the things that I have not done: friends I haven’t been to see, even though I promised and have had both time and opportunity to, and university work that I feel will soon be smothering me. It’s enough to place a weight on a person’s lungs that inhibits the breathing. It would’ve been nice to talk to someone tonight.
I am, of course, referring to the current upheaval about the cartoons about the prophet Muhammad that were published in a Danish newspaper last year (I don’t know why it’s only erupting now). I’ve been meaning to write about this for a week now and thought that the topic would be old and stale now, but after reading today’s newspaper, I know the fight is still going strong. The problem is two-fold: in Islam, it is blasphemous to depict holy figures in drawings, paintings and the like, the least of which not being caricatures. Secondly, some of the cartoons (with reference to one in particular) where very stereotypical about the West’s view of Muslims which is, bottom line, offensive, even to the non-zealots.
Being true to tradition, the West has very neatly summarized everything and placed it into pretty little categories: freedom of speech vs. respect of other nations and religions. Very tidy: something that makes for a good old fashioned debate in churches, schools, universities, water coolers and cigarette breaks. The West likes to believe they are very open minded, so everything is tolerated and considered for a while. Well, that’s what the ideology says.
Here’s a very concise version of what I think is the dirty little truth. Europe doesn’t like having to have non-Europeans in their midst. We saw it with the Jews and today we see it with the Muslims. They just don’t like throwing their doors open to strange folk who come in with strange customs and religions and eventually threaten their way of life. The problem is that the minorities aren’t minor anymore. Remember Paris? After September 11 some people feel that Arabs are free game for ridicule and blame and I guess a constant search for attacks on them eventually led to “The Cartoons”.
Muslims, on the other hand, just love to play the victim card. Wait, that’s more the Palestinians, but the fact is that they just love a good old rally with posters and protests and stuff. They are so sick and tired of everyone and everything else. The truth is that if the immigration situation was reversed (Europeans flooding the Arabian countries), the Europeans would probably have been treated just as worse, if not more. It’s a question of identity and “birds of a feather, flock together”. As a rule of thumb, different cultures aren’t compatible.
Freedom of Speech is a joke. There is no country in the world that has total freedom of speech. Some are just worse than others. To my knowledge, only “interregnum Germany” (pre-NAZI) briefly had total freedom of speech (i.e. absolutely no censorship whatsoever). Censorship is needed to protect against things like (child-) pornography and to protect governments from complots that sprout from dissent. Freedom of speech does not exist, so don’t ever come crying crocodile tears by me about it.
I am not a supporter of the Muslims, on the contrary. I do believe that some people are dealing with this in a proper and honourable manner, but that the most are irrational and vindictive. I also believe that certain things just shouldn’t be done.
Reading the newspaper today, I found an article entitled “Is it okay to hate Jews again?”. The article focused the growing amount of anti-Semitism that can be found not only among the protesting Muslims (apparently Jews should be blamed for the Danish cartoons...) but also among middle to upper class Westerners. As the author said, anti-Semitism flourished in Europe for nearly 2000 years and then just disappeared after the Holocaust (which is being contest anew by both Muslims and Westerners). It was probably unrealistic to think that it was gone for good, but the fact is that Jews and Israel are taking flak from multiple sides now. For me that’s just very sad, especially after I personally heard an anti-Semitic comment being made.
The problem is that issues are very rarely, if every, neatly catagorizable. There is almost always a myriad of other underlying issues.
I don’t want to say anything more about this issue. I’ve said more or less what I want. I’ll probably regret it or want to add or re-write some of it later, but I won’t, because it is not my intention of getting involved in this debate. This isn’t my fight and for all I care both sides can go jump into some sort of large body of water. There is merely one issue I want to raise: why would such radical reactions never be seen from Christians? The media is littered with blasphemous comics and sayings that have become commonplace. What would happen if all the Christians take to the streets to boycott all the cartoons, movies, television shows and publications that are blasphemous? What would happen if Hollywood is given an ultimatum over it’s beloved “oh my g*d” phrase? Sadly, we’ll never find out. Besides, even if that did happen, the rest of the world just wouldn’t care and continue as they would. Indeed, we would see and increase in blasphemous material. Yay for the little world we live in!
Having been docile for a couple of months now, it seems the bird flu scare is back with a vengeance: Nigeria, France, Germany and Egypt, amongst others, within a week? This is getting interesting.
I got a new phone last week! Yay. I’m terrible sorry, but I just had to mention that. It’s a Sony Ericsson K750i: the one I really wanted! This is the first time I have ever had a top-of-the-line (that I care about) phone. I’m not planning on turning into a yuppie now, but I am enjoying the GPRS and Java while the novelty still lasts (and it still does).
This evening feels very strange. Up until just now the streets felt unnervingly quiet. In Bellville the sky was filled with a thick cloud and mist blurred the near empty streets’ lights. Here, in Stellenbosch, the sky is clear and stars glisten as brightly as I haven’t seen them in a very long time. Everywhere it is very hot and I wonder why more people have not been enticed to go outside to enjoy the sweet and intoxicating summer’s night. I also have this strange feeling of having to be somewhere doing something. I know what it is, but that is just my ego and that insecure little boy inside thinking out loud. I am also aware of the things that I have not done: friends I haven’t been to see, even though I promised and have had both time and opportunity to, and university work that I feel will soon be smothering me. It’s enough to place a weight on a person’s lungs that inhibits the breathing. It would’ve been nice to talk to someone tonight.
